All posts
10 min read

What Is Employee Retention? Why How You Handle Annual Leave Decides Who Stays

By the Redstone HR team · Published

Subscribe to our newsletter

Read about our privacy policy.

What is employee retention? It is your ability to keep the people you want working for you over time, rather than losing them and having to rehire. In a small business, one of the most overlooked things that affects retention is how annual leave is handled: who gets cover, whether balances are right, and whether every holiday request gets a quick, fair answer.

What is employee retention, and why does it hit small businesses harder?

Employee retention is the share of your people who stay with you over a given period, and it is the other side of staff turnover. If you want to put numbers on the leaving side, here is how to calculate your employee turnover rate.

Retention hits small businesses harder because each person carries more. In a 10- or 30-person business, one good person leaving can mean clients or patients losing a familiar face, colleagues covering their work, and weeks spent recruiting and training a replacement. There is no bench of spare staff to absorb the gap.

Most retention advice talks about pay reviews, engagement surveys and career frameworks. That advice assumes an HR team. This guide looks at something a small business controls every week, without an HR department: how time off is requested, approved and recorded.

How can the way you manage annual leave push good people to leave?

Leave admin pushes good people away when it repeatedly leaves them stretched, short-changed or treated differently from colleagues. None of these moments is dramatic on its own, but they add up.

Overlapping leave leaves the rest of the team covering

When holiday requests are approved without seeing who else is off, two or three people can end up away on the same busy day. The people left behind cover client days, take the extra calls or see the extra patients. Your most reliable staff are often the ones who absorb this, and they are the ones you can least afford to lose.

Requests sit in inboxes or get refused late

When nobody checks cover at the time of asking, a holiday request either sits unanswered or gets approved and later reversed. Staff who have booked flights or childcare experience that as unfair, even when the reason is sound.

Balances drift between the spreadsheet, emails and paper forms

When the holiday spreadsheet, email threads and paper forms no longer agree, balances end up wrong. Staff dispute what holiday entitlement they are owed, and payroll gets corrected after the fact. Being told you have fewer days than you thought is a small but sharp knock to trust.

Absence is handled inconsistently

When short-term sickness is not recorded and scored the same way for everyone, one person's repeated odd days go unnoticed while another person's are questioned. Staff notice uneven treatment quickly.

The pressure is growing

According to HRO Today, a survey by AbsenceSoft found that rising leave and accommodation requests are outpacing HR capacity, with many HR teams missing deadlines. If organisations with HR teams are struggling, a small business without one feels it more: the extra load lands on the office manager, ops lead or founder who already has a full job.

Employee and management: why every holiday request is a trust moment

Every holiday request is a trust moment because, for most staff, booking time off is one of the most frequent direct dealings they have with management. How that goes shapes how they feel about the relationship between employee and management far more than an annual survey does.

A quick, fair and consistent answer builds trust. A slow, unclear or reversed answer erodes it, even when the person is told yes in the end.

The questions staff ask are a useful signal. If people keep asking "how many days have I got left?" or "can I carry holiday over?", the process is not transparent enough for them to check the answer themselves. Bank holidays, carry-over limits and different rules at different sites add to the confusion when the only source of truth is one person's memory or one spreadsheet.

Busy periods need the same clarity. If certain weeks are off limits, staff accept that more readily when the rule is written down and applied to everyone; see this guide to setting fair blackout dates for busy periods.

Why doesn't a better holiday spreadsheet fix it?

A better holiday spreadsheet doesn't fix the problem because a spreadsheet can record leave, but it cannot warn you about a coverage gap at the moment you say yes. The check that matters happens at the point of decision, and a spreadsheet is somewhere you look afterwards, if you remember.

A spreadsheet also cannot apply the Bradford Factor consistently, or keep each location's bank holidays, holiday entitlements and carry-over rules straight. Every one of those has to be done by hand.

Tidier spreadsheets and more reconciliation simply move the same hours of checking, chasing and correcting onto someone who already has a full job. The result is exactly what staff notice: wrong balances, late answers and uneven decisions.

Which approach to managing time off actually helps retention? An honest comparison

The approach that helps retention is the one that puts a cover check and an accurate balance into every decision, at a cost and effort a small business can sustain. Here is how the common options compare.

Approach What it does well Where it falls short for a 1–50 person business Spreadsheet plus email Free and familiar No coverage check at approval; no single trusted record; balances drift Hiring dedicated HR Brings expertise and judgement Often more than a 1–50 person team needs or can fund Full HR suite priced per user Covers many HR tasks in one place Cost rises with every hire, which makes budgeting awkward for a growing practice or a charity Focused leave management tool Covers requests, approvals, balances and absence records without full-suite overhead Not a payroll or benefits system, so those stay elsewhere

Whichever option you look at, ask one question first: can a manager see who else is off on the same screen as the approval, before saying yes to a holiday request? If that check is not part of the approval, overlapping leave can still leave you short-staffed.

What does a leave process that supports retention look like?

A leave process that supports retention runs from one trusted record in which the checks happen as part of the decision. In practice that means:

  • One record everyone believes. Every request, approval and balance lives in one place that staff and managers both trust, so there is nothing to reconcile.
  • Cover checked before yes. Managers see who else is out, with coverage warnings, before approving, so key days always have enough cover and nobody is left carrying the load.
  • Fair absence scoring. Absence is scored consistently as it is recorded, for example with the Bradford Factor, so conversations about sickness are based on the same measure for everyone.
  • Self-service answers. Staff check their own balances and get policy answers straight away, and the person in charge handles only genuine exceptions.
  • Rules set once. Each location's bank holidays, holiday entitlement and carry-over rules are set up once, and balances update automatically.

Protected, well-planned time off is also part of a healthy workload. For the wider picture, see these practical work-life balance strategies for employers.

Where Redstone HR fits, and the usual objections

Redstone HR is one way to get to that process: web-based leave management software that replaces holiday spreadsheets, email threads and paper forms with one place to request, approve and track time off. It is made by New Odyssey Limited in London and is built for small businesses where leave is handled alongside everything else.

What changes day to day:

  • Managers approve from a team calendar with coverage warnings, so overlapping leave is spotted before it is agreed.
  • Staff check their own balances and ask an AI policy assistant questions such as how many days they have left or whether they can carry holiday over.
  • Leave policies, bank holidays and carry-over rules can be configured per location.
  • Absence pattern detection includes Bradford Factor scores.
  • Scheduled reports and payroll-ready exports are available in CSV, Excel or PDF.
  • Calendars sync with Google Calendar and Outlook Calendar, and it connects with Google Workspace, Slack and Microsoft Teams.

Direct payroll integrations are planned but not live yet; today, payroll gets its figures through the exports.

"I don't have time to set up a new system." Typical setup time is about 15 minutes, and you can import staff from a spreadsheet or Google Workspace.

"Per-user software costs too much." Redstone HR is not priced per user. It is a flat monthly fee by headcount band: $49 a month for up to 15 people, $99 for 16 to 50, and $199 for 51 to 150, so hiring one more person within your band does not change the bill.

"Is there a mobile app?" There is no native iOS or Android app. Redstone HR is a web app used in any browser.

Self-assessment: is your leave process helping or hurting retention?

This self-assessment shows whether your leave admin is quietly costing you goodwill. Answer yes or no to each question:

  • Before approving a holiday request, can you see who else is off that day on the same screen?
  • Do your spreadsheet, emails and payroll agree on every person's balance right now?
  • Were you asked about remaining days, carry-over or bank holidays fewer than a handful of times this month?
  • Is short-term sickness recorded and scored the same way for everyone?
  • Could you produce leave figures for payroll in minutes rather than piecing them together?

Two or more "no" answers suggest your leave admin may be costing you goodwill with the people you most want to keep.

To see whether those frustrations are showing up in who actually stays, work out your employee retention rate and compare it over the last few years.

Frequently asked questions

What is employee retention in simple terms?

Employee retention is a business's ability to keep the people it wants over time instead of losing them and rehiring. It is the opposite side of staff turnover.

Can the way a small business handles annual leave really affect retention?

Yes: approving overlapping leave without seeing who else is off leaves colleagues covering, and wrong balances lead to disputes over holiday entitlement. Repeated small knocks like these wear down trust between staff and management.

Why isn't a holiday spreadsheet enough for a small business?

A holiday spreadsheet can record leave, but it cannot warn you about a coverage gap at the moment you approve a holiday request or apply the Bradford Factor consistently. Keeping it accurate moves hours of checking onto someone who already has a full job.

What should I ask a leave management software provider first?

Ask whether a manager can see who else is off on the same screen as the approval, before saying yes to a holiday request. If that check is not part of the approval, overlapping leave can still leave you short-staffed.

How much does Redstone HR cost?

Redstone HR is a flat monthly fee by headcount band rather than per user: $49 a month for up to 15 people, $99 for 16 to 50 and $199 for 51 to 150.