Sandwich Leave Policy: How to Handle Holiday Requests Around Weekends and Bank Holidays Without Leaving Your Small Business Short-Staffed
By the Redstone HR team · Published
Subscribe to our newsletter
Read about our privacy policy.
A sandwich leave policy decides whether the weekends and bank holidays that fall between two days of annual leave come out of someone's holiday entitlement. For a small business, the counting question is the easy part. The harder part is cover. The working days around bank holidays are the ones everybody wants, so they are where overlapping holiday requests leave you short-staffed. A good policy answers both questions: how sandwiched days are counted, and who gets them when everyone asks at once.
Why the days around bank holidays leave small teams short-staffed
The days between a bank holiday and a weekend leave small teams short because several people book them at once, often without anyone seeing the full picture. Book one or two days of annual leave next to a bank holiday and you get a long break, so the same dates fill up quickly. In a team of eight or twelve, two or three people off on the same Tuesday can mean nobody to answer client calls, see patients or run a service that people rely on.
The problem is rarely carelessness. In most small businesses, holiday requests are approved by an office manager, operations lead or founder alongside everything else. The record of who is off usually lives in a holiday spreadsheet, a few email threads and some paper forms, and these drift apart. When a request arrives, the person approving it may not see that someone else booked the same day by email last week.
The pressure is not easing. According to an AbsenceSoft survey reported by HRO Today, leave and absence requests are rising faster than HR teams can keep up with them. For a business with no HR team at all, that workload lands on someone who already has a full job.
So a sandwich leave policy has to answer two questions:
- How are weekends and bank holidays between leave days counted?
- When everyone wants the same days, how do you make sure there is still enough cover?
What is a sandwich leave policy?
A sandwich leave policy, sometimes called the sandwich rule, sets out whether non-working days that sit between two days of annual leave are deducted from holiday entitlement. Non-working days here usually means weekends and bank holidays.
A simple example: an employee books Friday and the following Monday off. Under a strict sandwich rule, the Saturday and Sunday in between would also count as annual leave, so four days come out of their holiday entitlement instead of two. Without a sandwich rule, only the two working days are deducted.
The term "sandwich leave" is more common in some other countries. In UK small businesses the same question tends to come up in other words: staff asking about "bridging" a bank holiday, or booking the working days between Christmas and New Year to get a long break for fewer days of leave.
Do weekends and bank holidays count as annual leave in the UK?
The common approach in the UK is to count annual leave in working days, so weekends and other days someone would not normally work are not deducted when they fall between leave days. If a person does not work Saturdays and Sundays, booking Friday and Monday off normally uses two days of holiday entitlement, not four.
Bank holidays need a clear line in your policy and in each employment contract. Some employers include bank holidays within holiday entitlement; others give them on top. Either way, staff should be able to read in plain words which applies to them and what happens if a bank holiday falls on a day they do not work.
The rules on holiday entitlement and bank holidays are set out by government, and they change from time to time. Check current GOV.UK guidance and take advice on your own contracts rather than relying on a general article. If your staff work in more than one country, the leave policy guides by country set out the local rules that apply where they are based.
Should a small business use a sandwich rule at all?
For most small businesses, a strict sandwich rule causes more trouble than it solves. The counting rule matters less than protecting cover on the days everyone wants.
The case against a strict rule is practical. Deducting weekends from holiday entitlement feels unfair to staff, who see days taken from them that they would never have worked. It also creates more disputes about what people are owed, and those disputes land on the same person who approves the holiday requests.
The case against having no approach at all is just as real. If anyone can book any day around a bank holiday, the popular dates fill up first-come, nobody checks cover, and the busy period runs itself until someone notices a gap on the day.
A fair middle ground looks like this:
- Count working days only. Weekends and days someone does not work are never deducted, and your treatment of bank holidays is written into the policy.
- Manage demand through cover rules, not deductions. Instead of making the popular days "cost" more, decide how many people can be off on them and how competing requests are settled.
This keeps the counting simple and puts the effort where the risk is: making sure key days are covered.
How to stop clashes on bridging days and peak holiday periods
You stop clashes by agreeing your cover rules in advance and making the who-else-is-off check part of every approval. Five steps cover most small businesses:
- Set a minimum cover for each role. Decide how many people in each role must be in on a normal working day, for example two receptionists or one qualified person per shift.
- Agree a simple rule, such as no more than one person per role off on the same day. Simple rules are easier to apply consistently and easier for staff to accept.
- Make sure whoever approves a holiday request can see who else is off before saying yes. If that check happens afterwards, or depends on memory, overlapping leave will still slip through.
- Decide in advance how competing requests are handled. First come, first served is easy to explain. A rota for the most popular dates, such as the days around Christmas or a bank holiday weekend, spreads them fairly over the years. Whichever you choose, write it into the policy.
- Use blackout dates only where cover genuinely cannot be found. Blocking leave on certain dates can be fair if it is limited, explained and announced early. This guide covers when blackout dates are fair and how to set them.
Why a better holiday spreadsheet will not fix it
A tidier holiday spreadsheet can record leave accurately, but it cannot warn you about a coverage gap at the moment you approve a request. The check still depends on the approver remembering to open the spreadsheet, scroll to the right week and spot the clash.
A spreadsheet also only works if someone updates it from every email and form. When those sources disagree, balances go wrong, payroll gets corrected after the fact, and staff dispute what they are owed. Around bank holidays, when requests bunch up, the gaps between the sources grow fastest.
Adding more reconciliation, such as a weekly check that the spreadsheet matches the inbox, does not remove the work. It moves the same hours of checking, chasing and correcting onto someone who already has a full job.
What good looks like: one record, with the cover check built into the approval
Good looks like a clear view of who is out before you say yes, so key days always have enough cover. Every holiday request, approval and balance sits in one record that everyone trusts, and the cover check happens as part of the decision rather than after it.
Redstone HR is one way to get there. It is web-based leave management software for small businesses, used in any browser. When a manager opens a holiday request, they see the team calendar and get coverage warnings at approval time, so a second person in the same role booking the Tuesday after a bank holiday is flagged before it is approved. Leave rules for each location, including bank holidays and carryover, are set once, and balances update automatically as requests are approved.
Employees can check their own balances and ask the AI policy assistant questions such as how a bank holiday affects their holiday entitlement. That means fewer interruptions for the office manager, who only needs to handle the genuine exceptions. The team calendar syncs with Google Calendar, Outlook Calendar, Google Workspace, Slack and Microsoft Teams, so people can see who is off in the tools they already use.
Redstone HR is set up in about 15 minutes and priced as a flat monthly fee by headcount band rather than per user, so hiring one more person does not change the bill.
How should the sandwich rule apply to part-time staff and other types of leave?
For part-time staff and shift workers, write the rule in terms of each person's own working days. "Weekends are not deducted" makes sense for someone who works Monday to Friday, but not for someone who works Wednesday to Saturday. Phrasing it as "only days you would normally work are deducted from annual leave" applies to everyone, whatever their pattern.
Bank holidays need the same care. A part-time employee may never work on a Monday, so decide and write down how bank holidays that fall on their non-working days are treated, and check current GOV.UK guidance before you finalise it.
Other types of time off can also land next to weekends and bank holidays:
- Compassionate leave is usually unplanned and should not be blocked by cover rules or blackout dates. See how compassionate leave works.
- Study leave often follows exam timetables rather than your busy periods, so agree in advance how it fits around popular dates. See study leave policies and employee rights.
- Sabbaticals are long enough that they will span weekends and bank holidays, so state whether bank holidays during a sabbatical are added back or lost. See planning a sabbatical around cover.
- Unpaid leave booked next to a weekend or bank holiday raises the same counting question; say whether non-working days in between are treated as unpaid. See unpaid leave rights and considerations.
Self-assessment: is your current process ready for the next bank holiday?
Answer yes or no to each question:
- Can you see who else is off on the same screen as the approval, before saying yes to a holiday request?
- Do you have a written minimum cover for each role?
- Does your policy state in plain words how weekends and bank holidays between leave days are counted?
- Do your spreadsheet, emails and forms agree on everyone's balance today?
- Can staff find their own holiday entitlement without asking you?
If you answered no to two or more, review your annual leave policy before the next busy period. Start with the counting rule (working days only, with bank holidays stated clearly), then add your minimum cover and how competing requests are settled.
Your next step: run through the self-assessment above, then check your rules for weekends, bank holidays and holiday entitlement against the leave policy guides by country before your next busy holiday period.
Frequently asked questions
What is a sandwich leave policy?
A sandwich leave policy sets out whether weekends and bank holidays that fall between two days of annual leave are deducted from an employee's holiday entitlement. Under a strict sandwich rule they are deducted; under the more common approach, only working days are counted.
If someone books Friday and Monday off, does the weekend count as annual leave?
Under the common UK approach, annual leave is counted in working days, so a Monday-to-Friday worker booking Friday and Monday off uses two days, not four. Check your policy, the employment contract and current GOV.UK guidance for your own situation.
Should a small business use a strict sandwich rule?
Most small businesses are better off counting working days only, because deducting weekends feels unfair to staff and leads to disputes. Busy dates around bank holidays are better managed with cover rules, such as no more than one person per role off on the same day.
How do I stop overlapping holiday requests around bank holidays?
Set a minimum cover for each role, agree a simple rule such as no more than one person per role off on the same day, and make sure whoever approves a holiday request can see who else is off before saying yes. Decide in advance how competing requests for popular dates are settled and write it into the policy.
Can a better holiday spreadsheet stop leave clashes?
A tidier holiday spreadsheet can record leave accurately, but it cannot warn you about a coverage gap at the moment you approve a request. It also depends on someone updating it from every email and form.
Keep reading
Leave Management Case Study: How a Small Business Stops Overlapping Annual Leave Leaving It Short-Staffed
A leave management case study for small businesses: why overlapping annual leave leaves you short-staffed, why spreadsheets fail, and what fixes it.
HR Capacity Planning for Small Businesses: How to Stop Overlapping Leave Leaving You Short-Staffed
HR capacity planning for small businesses: set minimum cover, see who is off before approving annual leave and stop being caught short on busy days.
What is a Form 16? A plain-English guide for small businesses, including how Part A and Part B are generated
What is a Form 16? A plain-English guide to what it certifies, how Parts A and B are generated, and why accurate leave records keep the figures right.
Salary in Advance: How UK Small Businesses Can Recover It Lawfully
Giving staff a salary in advance? How UK small businesses recover it lawfully: written agreements, deductions, final pay and leavers, without disputes.
Free tools: Holiday entitlement calculator · Bradford Factor calculator · Free leave templates · Leave law guides · HR glossary
