All posts
12 min read

What are software vendors? The questions a small business should ask HR software vendors before buying leave software

By the Redstone HR team · Published

Subscribe to our newsletter

Read about our privacy policy.

What are software vendors? They are companies that build and sell software, and for annual leave this usually means a cloud product you subscribe to monthly. Before you buy, the questions that matter are not about code or project plans. They are about whether the software stops you approving a holiday request blind, keeps one balance everyone trusts, and costs the same next month when you hire someone.

What are software vendors, and which kind are you buying from?

A software vendor is any company that makes or sells software. For a small business replacing a holiday spreadsheet, the vendor is almost always selling a ready-made, web-based product on a monthly subscription, often called SaaS (software as a service).

You may meet four kinds of vendor:

Type of vendor What they sell When a small business meets them Product vendor Ready-made software you subscribe to Most leave and HR tools Independent software vendor Software built on top of another platform Add-ons for tools you already use Reseller Someone else's software, sometimes bundled with support Through an IT or payroll provider Development agency Custom software built for you Rarely needed for leave management

Most advice on choosing a software vendor assumes a custom build. It talks about owning the code, scalability and managing a development project. That is sensible for a company commissioning bespoke software, and of little use to an office manager, ops lead or founder who needs to get holiday requests out of email.

The questions worth asking come from the problem you are solving, not from an IT procurement template. The rest of this guide is built around those problems.

Why small businesses end up with the wrong leave software

Small businesses usually choose the wrong leave software because they judge it on a demo of features rather than on whether it fixes the moment things go wrong. That moment is saying yes to a holiday request without seeing who else is off.

In most small businesses, leave is run by an office manager, ops lead or founder alongside everything else. It lives in a holiday spreadsheet, email threads and paper forms that slowly drift apart. Balances end up wrong, payroll gets corrected after the fact, and staff dispute what they are owed.

The two common fixes each solve a different problem. A tidier spreadsheet still moves the checking, chasing and correcting onto someone who already has a full job. A full HR suite priced per user is often more than a 1–50 person team needs, and the bill rises with every hire.

The pressure is not unique to the UK. According to Human Resources Director (hcamag.com), reporting on a survey of US employers, most are expanding leave programmes, but far fewer have the resources to administer them correctly, and small businesses without dedicated HR staff are the most exposed. The lesson carries across: the gap is usually in running leave, not in writing the policy.

Before you speak to any vendor, write down your top three leave problems. Every question below should trace back to one of them.

Questions about cover: will it stop us being short-staffed?

The right leave software shows a manager who else is off at the moment they approve a holiday request, not in a separate calendar afterwards. Ask vendors to demonstrate this live, using a day when two people from the same team want the same time off.

Questions to ask:

  • Can a manager see who else is off before approving a holiday request, on the same screen as the approval?
  • Does it warn about coverage gaps on key client, patient or service days, or does it only record leave?
  • Is there a team calendar, and does it show in the calendars and chat tools we already use?

Good looks like this: the check is part of the approval, not a step someone has to remember. If a manager has to open another tab to see who is out, the overlap that left you short-staffed last summer can still happen.

Questions about records: will everyone finally agree on balances?

Leave software is only worth switching to if it gives you one record of every request, approval and balance that everyone trusts. Ask how balances are calculated and when they update.

Questions to ask:

  • Is there one record of every request, approval and balance, and do balances update automatically when leave is approved?
  • Can it handle holiday entitlement, carryover rules and bank holidays per office or site if we have more than one location?
  • Can it produce payroll-ready figures, and in which formats? Is that a direct payroll integration or an export? Ask which is live today and which is only on the roadmap.
  • Can we import staff and opening balances from our current spreadsheet?
  • Does it record sickness absence consistently, for example with Bradford Factor scores, so patterns are spotted before they disrupt shifts?

The opening balances question matters more than it looks. If the numbers you start with are wrong, a new system simply records the old disputes more neatly. Agree opening balances with staff before you switch.

Questions about staff questions: will I stop being interrupted?

Good leave software lets employees check their own remaining annual leave and get answers to policy questions without coming to you. Ask vendors who answers the question "Can I carry holiday over?" once the system is live.

Questions to ask:

  • Can employees check their own remaining annual leave without asking me?
  • Who answers policy questions such as "Can I carry holiday over?" Is that an extra-cost add-on, or included in every plan?
  • How are answers kept in line with our own policy rather than generic rules?

The last question separates a useful assistant from a generic chatbot. Answers should come from the holiday entitlement and carryover rules you set, not from general internet advice. For a fuller picture, see what AI can realistically take off an office manager's plate.

Questions about set-up and time: do we have time to switch?

Most small businesses worry less about the software than about the project of switching. Ask each vendor for a specific set-up time for a team of your size and a list of what you need to prepare.

Questions to ask:

  • How long does a typical set-up take for a team of our size?
  • What do we need to prepare: staff list, opening balances, leave policy, bank holidays?
  • Are there sensible defaults, so we are not designing every rule from scratch?
  • Is there a free trial, do we need a card, and can we cancel without a long contract?

"No time to set up a new system" is usually a fear of a long project with no end date. A vendor that cannot give you a straight answer on set-up time is telling you something.

Questions about price: what happens to the bill when we hire?

The most important price question is what your bill will be after your next hire, not what it is today. Ask for the exact price at your current headcount and at your planned headcount in 12 months.

Questions to ask:

  • Is pricing per user, per seat or a flat fee by headcount band?
  • What triggers a price change?
  • What is included in every plan, and what is a paid add-on?
  • Have you changed or removed plans recently, and how long is the price you are quoting likely to hold?

That last question is timely. In November 2026, several recruiting and data software vendors dropped their free plans and moved small customers onto paid tiers, as reported by MindPattern. Plans that look cheap can change, so ask directly.

Predictable cost matters most for a growing practice or a charity on tight margins. If the price rises with each person added, every new starter means a new line on the invoice; with a flat fee by headcount band, the bill changes only when you move into a new band.

Questions about everyday use: phones, calendars and the tools you already have

Ask vendors for a written list of integrations that are live today, and decide in advance whether your staff need an app to download or whether a browser on their phone will do.

Questions to ask:

  • Is there an app to download from an app store, or is it a web app used in a phone's browser? Which do our staff actually need?
  • Which calendar and messaging tools does it connect to today, and which are only planned?
  • Can you give us a list of live integrations?

Treat "we can integrate with anything" as a non-answer. You want named tools, each marked live or planned.

Questions about compliance and data

Leave software should let you configure policies to match UK rules, but a straight vendor will tell you that compliance stays your responsibility. Be wary of anyone who says the software makes you compliant on its own.

Questions to ask:

  • Can the policies be configured to match UK rules on holiday entitlement and bank holidays for each location?
  • Who is responsible for compliance? Good vendors are clear that their tool supports your policy, but you remain responsible for it.
  • Can we get audit-ready records, and can we export our data if we leave?

RFP questions to ask software vendors: a lightweight version for a small business

A formal request for proposal (RFP) is usually overkill for a 1–50 person team, but sending the same written list of questions to every vendor still helps. It makes answers comparable and stops a polished demo from deciding for you.

A one-page brief to send each vendor:

  • Our top three leave problems, in a sentence each.
  • Headcount now and in 12 months.
  • Locations, and whether bank holidays or entitlements differ between them.
  • Must-have tools: the calendar, email and chat tools staff already use.
  • Budget: a monthly figure at today's headcount and next year's.
  • Set-up deadline: when you want leave running from the new system.

Ask every vendor to answer in writing and to mark each item "live today" or "planned". That one instruction filters out most roadmap promises.

Red flags in a vendor's answers

The clearest warning signs are vagueness about future cost and features that are not yet live presented as if they were. Watch for:

  • Vague answers about pricing at your next headcount band.
  • Roadmap features presented as if they are available now.
  • No straight answer on set-up time or what you need to prepare.
  • Approval workflows that never show who else is off.

How Redstone HR answers these questions

As one example of straight answers to the questions above, here is how Redstone HR, the leave management software we make, responds, including where it falls short.

  • Cover: managers see the team calendar and get coverage warnings before approving a holiday request.
  • Records: one record of requests, approvals and balances, with balances updated automatically. Leave types, carryover and bank holidays can be set per location. Absence is scored with the Bradford Factor. Payroll-ready exports are available in CSV, Excel or PDF.
  • Staff questions: employees check their own balances and ask the AI Policy Assistant, which is included in every plan.
  • Set-up: a typical set-up time of about 15 minutes, with staff imported from a spreadsheet or Google Workspace. There is a 14-day free trial, no credit card required, and you can cancel anytime.
  • Price: a flat monthly fee by headcount band, not per user, starting from $49 a month, for teams of up to 150.
  • Honest limits: Redstone HR is a web app used in any browser; there is no native iOS or Android app. Direct payroll integrations are planned, not live; payroll-ready exports are available today. Live integrations are Google Calendar, Outlook Calendar, Google Workspace, Slack and Microsoft Teams. It is not a full HR suite and does not handle payroll or benefits directly.
  • Compliance: policies can be configured to match your rules, but you remain responsible for compliance.

Self-assessment: score your current leave process before you talk to vendors

Answer yes or no to these five checks about how leave works in your business today:

  • Can you see who is off before approving a holiday request?
  • Does everyone agree on holiday balances?
  • Do staff find their own balances and policy answers without asking you?
  • Can you produce payroll figures for the month in minutes?
  • Would your software bill stay the same if you hired one more person?

Each "no" becomes the first question to put to every vendor. Three or more "no" answers usually mean the spreadsheet has stopped saving you time and is now costing it.

The aim is leave that runs largely on its own, with you handling only the genuine exceptions. Take your "no" answers into our guide to compare the best leave management software for small businesses and see which tools answer them.

Frequently asked questions

What are software vendors?

Software vendors are companies that build and sell software. For leave management, a small business is usually buying a ready-made cloud product on a monthly subscription rather than commissioning custom software.

What is the most important question to ask a leave software vendor?

Ask whether a manager can see who else is off on the same screen as the approval, before saying yes to a holiday request. If that check is not part of the approval, overlapping leave can still leave you short-staffed.

Does a small business need a formal RFP to choose HR software?

A formal request for proposal is usually overkill for a 1–50 person team. Sending every vendor the same one-page list of questions, and asking them to mark each answer "live today" or "planned", gives you most of the benefit.

How should I check whether HR software will cost more as we hire?

Ask each vendor for the exact monthly price at your current headcount and at your planned headcount in 12 months, and what triggers a price change. A flat fee by headcount band only changes when you move into a new band.

Who is responsible for holiday entitlement compliance if we use leave software?

You are. Leave software can be configured to match UK rules on holiday entitlement and bank holidays, but the employer remains responsible for compliance.